Former Cincinnati Reds pitcher Bronson Arroyo has always had a knack for singing. The past few weeks, he lit up the stage on "The Masked Singer."

Season 12 of "The Masked Singer" continued Wednesday night on FOX, with the Group C final in "Peanuts Night." Following the studio audience vote, Royal Knight became the first singer eliminated, followed by Sherlock Hound,

SPOILER ALERT! This story contains details from Thursday’s episode of The Masked Singer. Two more celebs were thrown out with the leftovers on Thanksgiving. Episode 9 was dubbed Peanuts Night. It kicked off with a performance by the Peanuts characters and panelists Robin Thicke and Rita Ora singing "You Make My Dreams Come True.