'One Tree Hill' co-star says he wanted to date Bethany Joy Lenz but cult got in the way
Singer Tyler Hilton, who had a recurring role on the teen drama, revealed this week he had tried to date co-star Bethany Joy ...
One Tree Hill’s Tyler Hilton Says He Tried to Date Bethany Joy Lenz But Her ‘Cult’ Didn’t Approve
Chris Keller and Haley James Scott IRL?! According to Tyler Hilton, he and Bethany Joy Lenz formed a close bond during One ...